The final votes are in, from Pitchfork, Drowned in Sound and The
Guardian, and AnyDecentMusic can at last give the final word on the
definitive Albums of 2009, in the Best Of The Best Ofs conclusive
listing.
We've rounded up the ratings from a series of Best Ofs. The end
result, we reckon, provides a comprehensive reflection of what's
been providing the maximum musical pleasure in the widest number of
reviewers' headphones for the past 12 months.
For anyone who's been paying attention, it's no surprise to see
Animal Collective a million miles ahead of the competition. If you
were a bookmaker, you'd have stopped taking bets on that sometime
around late spring.
And the odds on the Yeah Yeah Yeahs, Wild Beasts and Grizzly
Bear being up there would have been pretty short.
But there have been surprises. The XX came out of nowhere with
their debut album, as lauded in America as on home soil in the
UK.
And who could have foreseen electronic noise manipulators the
Fuck Buttons conquering all and sundry - even after they'd teamed
up with super-producer Andy Weatherall.
Eclectic pop of a variety of shades is well represented in the
upper reaches of the list, and it's probably fair to say that on
this evidence, indie pop has been the most fertile ground during
the past 12 months.
British rock also retains a healthy presence, with The Horrors,
the Manics and Kasabian flying the flag.
It's not been a vintage year for hip hop, however, with the most
respectable showings coming from a couple of veterans, Raekwon and
Mos Def, and similarly, fans of extreme guitar noise will have to
scour the list to find material to their liking.
Who knows, it could all change next year. That's why we love
it.
Top 10: Uncut, Mojo, Q, Music OMH, Clash, NME, The
Quietus, Spin, Sunday Times, Pop Matters, Pitchfork, Drowned in
Sound, The Guardian, Line Of Best Fit, Rolling Stone
(10 for 1st place, 9 for 2nd etc)
- 112 Animal Collective Merriweather Post
Pavilion
- 57 The XX XX
- 52 Grizzly Bear Veckatimest
- 51 Wild Beasts Two Dancers
- 49 Yeah Yeah Yeahs It's Blitz
- 44 The Dirty Projectors Bitte
Orca
- 42 Phoenix Wolfgang Amadeus Pheonix
- 36 Fuck Buttons Tarot
Sport
- 33 The Horrors Primary Colours
- 26 Manic Street Preachers Journal For..
- 25 Fever Ray Fever
Ray
- 23 Florence & The Machine Lungs
- 17 St Vincent
Actor
- 12 Bob Dylan Together Through Life
- 12 U2 No Line On The Horizon
- 10 Kasabian West Ryder Pauper Lunatic
Asylum
- 10 Raekwon Only Built 4 Cuban
Linx... Pt. II
- 10 Sunn O))) Monoliths And Dimensions
- 09 Bat For Lashes Two Suns
- 09 Bill Callahan Sometimes I Wish We
Were...
- 09 Neko Case Middle Cyclone
- 09 Noah And The Whale The First Days Of
Spring
- 09 Nneka No Longer At Ease
- 09 Bruce Springsteen Working On A?Dream
- 09 Super Furry Animals Dark Days/Light
Years
- 08 The Avett Brothers I And Love And You
- 08 Richard Hawley Truelove's Gutter
- 07 The Flaming Lips Embryonic
- 07 Girls Album
- 07 Jay-Z The Blueprint 3
- 07 Madness The Liberty Of Norton Folgate
- 06 Green Day 21st Cebtury Breakdown
- 06 HEALTH Get Colour
- 06 Tinariwen Imidiwn: Companions
- 05 Arctic Monkeys Humbug
- 05 Jamie T Kings And Queens
- 05 Oneida Rated O
- 04 Gyratory System The Sound Board
Breathes
- 04 Mos Def The Ecstatic
- 04 The Big Pink A Brief History Of Love
- 04 The Hidden Cameras Origin: Orphan
- 04 Muse The Resistance
- 04 The Twilight Sad Forget The Night
Ahead
- 04 Wilco Wilco (The Album)
- 03 The-Dream Love Vs Money
- 03 Gnaw Their Tongues All The Dread...
- 03 Lily Allen It's Not Me, It's You
- 03 Mastodon Crack The Sky
- 03 Micachu And The Shapes Jewelry
- 03 Monsters Of Folk Mosnters Of Folk
- 03 Sonic Youth The Eternal
- 02 Andrew Weatherall A Pox On The
Pioneers
- 02 Drake So Far Gone
- 02 Japandroids Post-nothing
- 02 La Roux La Roux
- 01 Cold Cave Love Comes Close
- 01 Dave Rawlings Machine A Friend Of A
Friend
- 01 The Dead Weather Horehound
- 01 Miranda Lambert Revolution
- 01 Paramore Brand New Eyes
And the ADM top 20
- 8.4 Animal Collective
- 8.4 Sun O)))
- 8.3 Grizzly Bear
- 8.3 Fuck Buttons
- 8.2 Yeah Yeah Yeahs
- 8.1 The XX
- 8.1 Tinariwen
- 8.1 Raekwon
- 8.0 Dave Rawlings Machine
- 8.0 The Dirty Projectors
- 8.0 Fever Ray
- 7.9 Manic Street Preachers
- 7.8 HEALTH
- 7.8 Micachu And The Shapes
- 7.8 Sonic Youth
- 7.7 Girls
- 7.7 Madness
- 7.7 Mos Def
- 7.7 Wilco
- 7.7 Wild Beasts