William Tyler
Time Indefinite
One of the most compelling albums Tyler has made. .... Time Indefinite seems to stare into the heart of what the country is tight now, in all its fragmented, polarised turmoil; the state of the nation in perfect sync with Tyler's own troubled state of mind. Print edition only
Uncut
William Tyler
Time Indefinite
The Nashville guitarist’s latest album is an act of reckoning: Collaging together found sounds and field recordings with his own fingerpicking, it feels like an elegy for a nation in free fall
Pitchfork
William Tyler
Time Indefinite
William Tyler offers a fresh and uniquely compelling way to affirm that it’s OK not to be OK: these are humbly majestic anthems for our anxious age
The Line Of Best Fit
William Tyler
Time Indefinite
Though less immediate and accessible than his earlier work, Time Indefinite is another career highlight that pushes Tyler boldly into the futur
All Music
Car Seat Headrest
The Scholars
Toledo is young enough that it's premature to call The Scholars a masterpiece, though it's unquestionably his finest work to date and one of the best albums of 2025
All Music
Car Seat Headrest
The Scholars
Packed with musical and literary references, there's a lot to unpick, but tracks like "The Catastrophe (Good Luck With That, Man)" show the band still have a knack for pop hooks, albeit not as lo-fi as before. Print edition only
Uncut
Car Seat Headrest
The Scholars
It's the jubilant reach and dynamite in the details that make The Scholars a rock opera worthy of the form. Print edition only
Mojo
PUP
Who Will Look After The Dogs?
Delivers a treasure trove of head-bobbing catharsis. Who Will Look After the Dogs is messy, brutal, and also strangely comforting; it’s an album that doesn’t clean up after itself and doesn’t need to
Northern Transmissions
PUP
Who Will Look After The Dogs?
A mixture of driving punk energy, wry humour and moments of vulnerability
The Arts Desk
PUP
Who Will Look After The Dogs?
Toronto band take on personal crisis with a sense of humor and loud guitars
Rolling Stone
PUP
Who Will Look After The Dogs?
It’s all catharsis, set to an instrumentation that simply sounds like a really good rock show as they refused to overthink or overdo craft either and more than benefit from that no-brain, all-guts approach
Far Out
PUP
Who Will Look After The Dogs?
There are no easy answers, just four friends muddling their way through life and trying to put words to what their feeling. It’s the crowning glory of their peerless five-album run
Dork