-
8.5
72402
8.5 |
Earbuddy
The tunes are more pop overall, occasionally venturing into country (“Mistral”) or surf-guitar (“Easy Come, Easy Go”), but never losing the thread that ties all of their catalog together
Read Review
-
8.4
72549
8.4 |
Sputnik Music (staff)
It’s the perfect album to sit around a fire with…to be out on the lake with…to be alone in thought with
Read Review
-
8.0
72397
8.0 |
All Music
An album where the creative sprawl is more a matter of how this divergent selection of melodies and moods interacts, rather than how many elements can be folded into one song
Read Review
-
8.0
72430
8.0 |
Rolling Stone
Maybe because Meloy is now a published author (he's penned a trilogy of popular children's books), his songwriting wit seems to have grown sharper and less showoff-y
Read Review
-
8.0
72157
8.0 |
Mojo
A set heavier on emotion and melody than their previous work, which retains familiar echoes of amplified British folk. Print edition only
-
8.0
72182
8.0 |
The Music
While it remains within a very strict and recognisable set of Decemberists sounds, it still manages to find plenty of variation within those limits
Read Review
-
8.0
72197
8.0 |
Drowned In Sound
The album is a collection of songs from a band at the peak of their powers having their cake and eating it too
Read Review
-
8.0
72198
8.0 |
musicOMH
The lack of cohesion for the album as a whole may prove to be a turn off for many. For others, though, it’s likely to still be spinning when the band’s name comes around on the calendar once again
Read Review
-
8.0
72233
8.0 |
DIY
It is safe to assume, the longer you spend with this record and the deeper into it you sink, the greater it will grow
Read Review
-
8.0
72273
8.0 |
PopMatters
They’re still one of the best modern bands around, and this record will surely be regarded as one of the year’s best come the end of 2015
Read Review
-
8.0
72282
8.0 |
The 405
Scored through with the group's idiosyncracies but what there is, as well, is maturity, ambition and variety, all of which conspire to form the basis of a very fine indie rock record
Read Review
-
8.0
72285
8.0 |
The Guardian
It’s another fantastic, emotional album from a band taking heartfelt stock of where they’ve been and who they are
Read Review
-
8.0
72286
8.0 |
The Irish Times
It’s a satisfying record that quenches a thirst for quality songwriting
Read Review
-
8.0
72328
8.0 |
The Observer
Best of all is the joyful pop of Cavalry Captain, as irrepressible as it is infectious. A fine return
Read Review
-
8.0
72349
8.0 |
God Is In The TV
It’s one of those albums that when it’s finished not only do you want to go back and listen to it all over again, but it also makes you want to go and check out their back catalogue
Read Review
-
8.0
72373
8.0 |
Crack
A delightful addition to the band’s discography, one that both showcases the band’s versatility and beautifully exposes their depth of feeling
Read Review
-
7.6
72433
7.6 |
Paste Magazine
Just another chapter in the already punctuated saga of one of rock’s best modern lyricists and his talented ban
Read Review
-
7.5
72438
7.5 |
Beardfood
They may have toned down, but at times their tunes are still larger than life
Read Review
-
7.5
72384
7.5 |
A.V. Club
It’s the sound of a band unafraid of taking chances, and succeeding more often than not
Read Review
-
7.0
72275
7.0 |
Slant Magazine
Much bigger sounding, musically diverse effort than its concise, uniform predecessor
Read Review
-
7.0
72158
7.0 |
Uncut
Less words, more heart
Read Review
-
7.0
72126
7.0 |
The Line Of Best Fit
Has some wonderful songs and does emit glints of growth, even if it is a tad long and flabbier than previous outings
Read Review
-
7.0
72460
7.0 |
Spin
More than a decade on, this band is peeking out from behind the veil of obfuscation in an effort to stay relevant
Read Review
-
7.0
72346
7.0 |
The Digital Fix
While there may no longer be songs about abandoned orphans or man-eating whales, The Decemberists prove they can, if nothing else, just deliver some good quality listening
Read Review
-
6.7
72177
6.7 |
Pretty Much Amazing
An album with this much warmth, this much pleasantness, in the midst of a harsh winter should be, at the very least, appreciated
Read Review
-
6.7
72280
6.7 |
Consequence Of Sound
As a singles-driven pop record, it might garner a hit or two; as a Decemberists record, it ever-so-slightly misses the mark
Read Review
-
6.0
72127
6.0 |
The Skinny
A coherent, mostly engaging, albeit slightly overlong piece of work
Read Review
-
6.0
72294
6.0 |
Under The Radar
It reveals a band older, wiser, and less reliant on the quirks and gimmicks of earlier releases
Read Review
-
6.0
72462
6.0 |
State
The record works when the band either strip it back or pile it on, the frequent moments when they just play it down the middle fail to make an impression
Read Review
-
6.0
72518
6.0 |
Q
It's emotional intelligence shines out, but a little more of the earlier records' fleetness and dash wouldn't hurt either. Print edition only
-
5.6
72339
5.6 |
Pitchfork
The failure of this album, in addition to being overlong and under-ambitious, is the idea that maturity should beget lazy, hammock songs
Read Review
-
4.0
72321
4.0 |
The FT
Stodgy and uninvolving in comparison with their past adventures
Read Review
-
4.0
73150
4.0 |
No Ripcord
Ultimately balances out as a fairly middling work
Read Review
-